Cover Picture

Cheesy Peanut Butter & Pickle Sandwich

in Food

I have been eating pickle and peanut butter sandwiches as far back as I can remember. I tried finding out when the sandwich was first created. The closes answer I found was during the Great Depression. It may go back further than that. I did find find out Elvis Presley and Hemingway liked to eat peanut butter and pickle sandwiches. 

I love eating peanut butter and pickle sandwiches so much that I added and mixed up the ingredients. The original peanut butter and pickle sandwich only had three ingredients. Which are Pickles, peanut butter and your choice of bread. I like to add cheese or turkey bacon. Sometimes I like to fry my sandwich to add a buttery taste on the outside of the bread.

One question I get asked a lot when eating peanut butter and pickle sandwiches in front of friends is what kind of pickles do you use dill, sweet or bread n butter. The answer is simple. Use your favorite kind of pickle. I suggest trying different flavors of pickles to figure out which you like best.

This how I make a peanut butter and pickle sandwich :

First thing I do is choose which kind of bread I will be using. I like the "Sandwich Skinnys", as they are thinner than most breads. 

Next I spread a healthy serving of peanut butter on both slices of bread. The peanut butter holds the ingredients on to keep from falling out of the bread while eating.

Next I add a slice of cheese. This slice of cheese is Gouda. Really any kind of cheese will do. Choose our favorite or what is available.  

Next I add as many pickles as I can get on one layer. I top it with the other slice bread with peanut butter.

If I have turkey bacon, I will add it between the slice of cheese and peanut butter on the piece of bread.

Do you like eating peanut butter and pickle sandwiches? How do you prepare your version?

Niume community

user thumb user thumb
{{postData.response.imageUploadPercent}}% Complete more less
Hype {{comment.hype}}
Hype {{reply.hype}}
{{comment.response.imageUploadPercent}}% Complete

Facebook comments


Please tell us the reason for your report.

Reasons to Remove this post:

Add a comment (optional)

* please select at least one reason.

* unable to remove post.

Share: {{::postData.title}}

Your post has been published! Now share it to reach more people.

Make sure you check our Resources Page with tips and videos to increase the reach of your posts.


Are you sure you want to delete this post?